Most new flat roofs on the lakeshore are one of three single-ply membranes: EPDM, TPO or PVC. All three work here. The right one depends on what's below the roof, what comes out of the vents, and how the roof will be used and maintained.
The quick comparison
| EPDM | TPO | PVC | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Black (white available) | White | White or gray |
| Seams | Taped (adhesive) | Heat-welded | Heat-welded |
| Typical life | 20–30 years | 15–25+ years | 20–30 years |
| Typical cost | $5.50–$11 / sq ft | $6–$12 / sq ft | $7–$14 / sq ft |
| Grease / chemicals | Poor | Fair | Good |
| Cold flexibility | Excellent | Good | Good |
EPDM: the cold-climate workhorse
EPDM is a synthetic rubber. It stays flexible well below zero, tolerates the freeze and thaw that the lake creates, and has been used on northern roofs for decades. Its weak points are its seams, which are taped rather than welded, and its sensitivity to grease. On a well-built EPDM roof the seams use primer and tape, and the flashings are cured or uncured EPDM bonded properly at every wall and curb.
TPO: welded and reflective
TPO is a thermoplastic sheet whose seams are fused with hot air, so the roof becomes one continuous membrane. It's white, which cuts cooling costs on air-conditioned buildings, and it's competitively priced. Its quality depends on the welds, which should be probed, and on the brand and thickness. On windy sites, the fastening pattern at corners and edges matters as much as the sheet.
Roof leaking right now?
Manitowoc Superior Flat Roofing repairs, coats and replaces commercial and flat roofs across Manitowoc County and the lakeshore, with a written price before any work starts. Request a quote online and we’ll call you back.
PVC: for grease and chemicals
PVC is also heat-welded but resists fats, oils and many chemicals that soften rubber and asphalt. That makes it the usual choice for restaurants, food and cheese plants and process buildings. It costs more, but on those roofs it saves on repeat repairs around exhaust fans.
Where modified bitumen fits
Modified bitumen isn't single-ply, but it still covers many storefronts, small commercial roofs and residential flat roofs. It's tough underfoot and handles roofs with lots of walls, corners and penetrations. See modified bitumen roofing.
What matters most near the lake
- Attachment: fastening density at corners and perimeter, or a fully adhered system, matters more than the membrane brand.
- Edges: tested edge metal and properly cleated copings keep wind from getting under the roof. See wind damage on lakeshore flat roofs.
- Drainage: any membrane ages faster under standing water and ice.
- Maintenance: clean drains and checked flashings add years to any of them.