Manitowoc, WI & the Lakeshore Mon – Sat · Leak Calls 7 Days a Week
Home › Blog › Planning
Planning

Roof Recover vs. Full Replacement: How to Decide

A recover puts a new roof over the old one. It skips the tear-off, which saves money, keeps the building closed to the weather during the work and keeps old roofing out of the landfill. But it only works when the existing roof qualifies.

What the code allows

Wisconsin's commercial building code adopts the International Building Code. Under the IBC's re-roofing rules, a recover generally isn't allowed over a roof that is water-soaked or deteriorated so it isn't a suitable base, or over a roof that already has two or more roof coverings. So the first question is always what's already there.

When a recover makes sense

  • Only one existing roof covering.
  • Insulation mostly dry, with wet areas small enough to cut out and replace.
  • Sound deck.
  • Roof height at walls, doors and curbs leaves room for the new layers.

When it has to come off

  • Two roof coverings already in place.
  • Widespread wet insulation.
  • Deck damage or rust that needs inspecting and replacing.
  • Serious ponding that needs tapered insulation and drain changes.

Roof leaking right now?

Manitowoc Superior Flat Roofing repairs, coats and replaces commercial and flat roofs across Manitowoc County and the lakeshore, with a written price before any work starts. Request a quote online and we’ll call you back.

Core cuts settle it

A core cut is a small sample through the roof down to the deck. It shows how many layers there are, what the insulation is and whether it's wet. Several cores plus a moisture survey give a reliable picture of the whole roof. See leak detection and moisture surveys.

A lakeshore note

On a recover, the new membrane has to be fastened or adhered through the old roof to the deck, and the edges rebuilt. On exposed buildings near the lake, that edge and corner work deserves the same attention as on a new roof. See wind damage on lakeshore flat roofs.

Making the call

A recover on the right roof is a smart way to save. On the wrong roof it buries problems that come back. See roof recover and overlay and replacement and installation.


More roofing guides

Questions & Answers

Frequently asked questions

A new roof installed over an existing one, with a cover board or insulation between, without tearing off the old roof.

Building codes based on the International Building Code generally allow a recover only over a single existing roof. With two roofs already in place, it comes off.

Recovers typically run about $4–$8 per square foot versus about $6–$13 for tear-off and replacement.

No. Wet areas must be removed and replaced first, and a water-soaked roof isn’t a candidate.

Roof leaking?

Leak repair, coatings and replacement for commercial and flat roofs across Manitowoc County and the lakeshore. Tell us about the roof. You get a written price before any work starts.

Request a Quote